Monday, March 14, 2011

Keep It Simple, Stupid

ChannelNewsAsia kept playing the video clip over and over on national television, of Finance Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam rebutting Opposition leader Low Thia Khiang's contention that the Goods and Services Tax is hurting the lower-income group.  Altogether now, let's say it one more time, GST is a regressive tax.

While Tharman got his knickers in a twist trying desperately to avoid using the "R" word, he could only get so far as to declare that, "on its own, the GST is a flat tax" and "not a progressive tax". Oh, he did throw in the colourful graphs and stuff about "Grow and Share package" and "special transfers to help the lower- and middle-income groups", one time exercises that seem to crop up only in an election year. The "GST plus" invention - workfare and the other schemes - can hardly be of solace to the Ah Soh who collects cardboard and empty cans for threadbare subsistence.  Tharman chose to ignore the fact that the GST millstone is there for all perpetuity, once PM Lee Hsien Loong hiked it from 5% to 7% at one go.  The combobulation of after measures following the implementation only serve to confirm the short comings of poor decision making.

The genius of Low's counter argument is in it's simplicity, "Why you first of all tax the low-income family and give him offset package?" Indeed, would you let someone cut your finger so he can give you a free band-aid?

To illustrate that the rich contribute to the bulk of the GST receipts, Tharman coughed up the statistic that the GST paid by the lower-income group - up to the 60th percentile - formed about 16 per cent of all GST collected. Big deal. We know the GST for a $45 cut of porterhouse steak at Morton's is several times the GST on a $3.50 plate of chicken rice. So is the $133,000+ monthly pay check (for someone in Tharman's tax bracket) several times more than the $2,000 per month some families are surviving on in First World Singapore. What Tharman and people of that ilk fail to comprehend is that the poor can seldom afford to eat out in the first place. For them, survival is affordable rice, cooking oil, salt and sugar. Exactly why Low made the call for the Finance Minister to reduce GST from 7 to 5 per cent and to waive the tax for basic necessities. As Confucius would say, "Life is really simple, but we (they) insist on making it complicated."


  1. Its a fact that the total quantum of GST paid by the rich is higher, but time and time again we keep on saying that the MIW failed to miss the point. Or did they? Im sure what the street's opinions of GST being regressive is also knowledge to them.

  2. All these arrogant politicians would never have been elected in any other democracies. They are the Singapore equivalent of the central committee in China that can never be booted out of power.

  3. Cabinet ministers are part of the elite. They have never had to really makes ends meet. Their statistics are meaningless in the face of human struggle and want.

    Excuse me but what does the GST finance? Cabinet salaries, defense expenditure etc...

  4. This is called lying with statistics!

  5. Budget gives more than required - Ministers' Pay?

  6. The GST increase is to help the poor.

    Yes, the poor President, the poor Ah Lee PAPA and his team of Forty Thieves and possibly thousands of running dogs to screw the common peasants.

    Have we ever heard of how they spend their party funds buying shark fins and abalone porridge to con the peasants ?

  7. If you cannot afford to give it to the poor, the least you can do is not to steal from them.

  8. every dollar not spent to benefit citizens means more for themselves, like $890,000 extra for Nathan...a prelude to their own increment.

    to me, only scums of the earth steal from the poor and claim it's a good system.

  9. Idiot people, complain complian but in the end vote for the PAP. You deserve another dose of our very competent extremely expensive government, who don't give a shit about the people.

  10. I visited several blogs but the audio feature for audio songs existing
    at this website is genuinely superb.
    my website ::

  11. I go to see day-to-day some blogs and websites to read content, however this blog provides quality based posts.
    Take a look at my web page ... free porno

  12. Hey there! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new iphone 4! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Keep up the great work!
    Here is my blog ; teenporn

  13. If you want to grow your familiarity simply keep visiting this web page and be updated with the most up-to-date news posted here.
    Here is my weblog : teen porn

  14. Thanks , I have recently been searching for information approximately
    this subject for a while and yours is the greatest I've discovered so far. But, what concerning the bottom line? Are you certain concerning the source?
    Look into my homepage ... contractors in Orlando

  15. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog posts.

    Any way I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently
    Feel free to surf my site ... Orlando fl hookah lounge